6 Examples of Social Media Crises: What can we learn?

It is not uncommon for a large company to have to deal with a social media crisis, but some handle them better than others.

10040 20
10040 20
social media crisis

It is not uncommon for a large company to have to deal with a social media crisis and some handle them better than others.

We recently hosted a webinar on How to Effectively Manage a Social Media Crisis which produced some interesting examples and highlighted what we can learn from them.

How not to handle a social media crisis: Applebee’s

What happened: A pastor who had eaten at an Applebee’s restaurant crossed out the automatic 18% tip charged for parties of more than eight and wrote “I give God 10% why do you get 18” above her signature. A waitress at the restaurant took a photo of this and posted it on Reddit. She was subsequently fired for “violating customer privacy” which would have been understandable if Applebee’s had not posted a similar receipt that was complimenting them just 2 weeks prior.

As news of this incident spread like wildfire and infuriated people across all social media platforms, Applebee’s responded with a short post defending their actions on their Facebook page. This quickly drew over 10,000 mostly negative comments, to which Applebee’s started responding by posting the same comment over and over again. They were also be accused of deleting negative comments and blocking users.

The downward spiral continued as Applebee’s persisted to defend their actions and argue with users that criticised them. By the following day, after the original post had generated over 19,000 comments, Applebee’s decided to hide the post which only created more anger.

What we can learn: Applebee’s defensive and even argumentative approach amplified the whole situation and blocking users, tagging users in repetitive posts and hiding criticism only make things worse. The bottom line? Arguing with Facebook users is always a bad idea.


A social media crisis handled with honesty and speed: Kitchenaid

What happened: An insensitive tweet about President Obama’s grandmother was posted to the Kitchenaid Twitter account, instead of the personal account of a KitchenAid staff member. The tweet was quickly deleted, but many people had already seen it. The head of the Kitchenaid brand, Cynthia Soledad, took to the Twitter account just 15 minutes later and explained what had happened. She apologised to President Obama and the public and pointed out that the person who posted this will no longer be tweeting for them.

What we can learn: First of all, this emphasises the importance of keeping personal and company accounts separate, but if a mistake does happen it should be addressed immediately. Time moves very quickly on social media, so companies need to take decisive action as quickly as Cynthia Soledad did. Her honest explanation and personal apology was well received and the damage to the brand reputation was limited as a result.


Other notable examples

 

DKNY: After a photographer realised that DKNY were using his photos in a window display without his permission,  he mobilised his community to share a post asking DKNY to donate $100,000 to a local YMCA in lieu of compensation. DKNY responded quickly by way of an apology. They explained that the Bangkok store involved had accidently used the ‘mock-up’ photos and they promised to donate $25,000 to the YMCA. The photographer accepted it was an honest mistake and thanked them for the donation. DKNY’s quick and strong response successfully defused the situation before a social media crisis erupted.


Burger King: The Burger King Twitter account was recently hacked and the person who gained access to the account changed the name to McDonald’s and began promoting McDonald’s in their tweets. By the time Burger King had regained control of their account and issued an apology, they had gained 30,000 new followers. This led some to suggest it wasn’t a crisis at all, but actually wielded positive results. Either way, it taught us all a lesson in the importance of password security.


HMV: HMV (a UK entertainment retailer) recently laid off a large number of staff without considering the fact that some still had access to the corporate Twitter account. One member of staff took advantage of this by live tweeting the “mass execution of loyal employees who love the brand”. It seems that no one in senior management knew the Twitter password and they were powerless to stop it.


O2: During a massive network outage, O2’s Twitter account became inundated with tweets by frustrated customers. Instead of issuing standard corporate responses, O2 responded directly to these tweets with an honest and light-hearted demeanor. Their human approach was extremely refreshing and sentiment changed dramatically as a result.

You can listen to the recording of the webinar here or read our more recent post, 11 Ways to Avoid a Social Media Crisis

Are there any other examples you would add?

Related Post

In this article

Join the Conversation

20 comments

  1. 6 Examples of Social Media Crises: What can we learn? | Our Social Times | digitalnews2000 Reply

    […] on oursocialtimes.com Share this:TwitterFacebookLike this:Like Loading… This entry was posted in Uncategorized by […]

  2. Making the most of a social media crisis: how to gain followers and influence people | Frayne Media Reply

    […] So what do I mean by a social media crisis? That moment when you’re trending but it’s not the result of a clever PR campaign. When the whole world is looking at you because someone’s tweeted something controversial or inappropriate, made an unfortunately placed spelling mistake or your account’s been hijacked by disgruntled employees… (see Our Social Times’ 6 Examples of Social Media Crises). […]

  3. Listly List - Kryzysy w social mediach #casiestudy #kryzyswsocialmediach #facebook #twitter Reply

    […] 6 Examples of Social Media Crises: What can we learn? […]

  4. Managing Social Media Chatter, Complaints, Conflicts and Crises~ By Tami Wessley | Increase Your Visibility To Your WebSite Reply

    […] all had painful social media mishaps. Some of these brands  were able to minimize the negative impact by handling their situations […]

  5. How to Handle a Social Media Crisis - Coles & Colomy, Creative | Publishing Reply

    […] you are faced with a social media emergency, let us have a moment of silence for the major corporations who did not handle a crisis in an appropriate way. From Applebee’s to Burger King, sometimes […]

  6. 9 brands prove vulnerability is good for business Reply

    […] DKNY: After a photographer realized that DKNY was using his photo in a window without his permission, he mobilized his community to share a post asking DKNY to donate $100,000 to a local YMCA in lieu of compensation. DKNY responded quickly by way of an apology that it was an accident promised to donate $25,000 to the YMCA. The photographer accepted it was an honest mistake and thanked them for the donation. […]

  7. 9 Brands Prove Vulnerability is Good for Business | Total Web Design Reply

    […] DKNY: After a photographer realized that DKNY was using his photo in a window without his permission, he mobilized his community to share a post asking DKNY to donate $100,000 to a local YMCA in lieu of compensation. DKNY responded quickly by way of an apology that it was an accident promised to donate $25,000 to the YMCA. The photographer accepted it was an honest mistake and thanked them for the donation. […]

  8. The woes of a social media manager Reply

    […] message, share, upload and tweet. And despite the best social media training, you could make one small slip up and BOOM, it all goes down from […]

  9. Businesses and Social Media: The Good, the Bad and the Takeaways | Work With Marcel Schmidt Reply

    […] The Bad: When an Applebee’s server posted a photo of a receipt where a customer failed to leave a tip, Applebee’s fired the server for violating customer privacy. […]

  10. Businesses and Social Media: The Good, the Bad and the Takeaways | My Business Online Reply

    […] The Bad: When an Applebee’s server posted a photo of a receipt where a customer failed to leave a tip, Applebee’s fired the server for violating customer privacy. […]

  11. Social Media Crisis and Businesses | Squintwire Reply

    […] We all have witness to corporations being trapped by a social media crisis. Here are just a few provided by OurSocialTimes.com. You can see the full posting by clicking here. […]

  12. Social Media Opportunities Are Created With Timing | Aaron WeicheAaron Weiche Reply

    […] results, you also need to be ready to act quickly and correctly when things go awry.  There are many documented social media fires, but the manner in which some companies handle them can even improve their customers perception of […]

  13. Crisis! Crisis! Crisis! | Publications on PR Reply

    […] Thompson, H. (2013, February 28). 6 examples of social media crises: What can we learn?. Retrieved from http://oursocialtimes.com/6-examples-of-social-media-crises-what-can-we-learn/ […]

  14. Principle : Honesty | pc8zc Reply

    […] this article found from Out Social Times it talks about how some companies had an issue with honesty.  The […]

  15. Ashley Reply

    I love these sorts of posts. I read the brand failures books and loved them, so this sort of thing suits me down to the ground.

  16. Vicky Reply

    You might want to take a look at what is going on with Grazia’s Facebook at the moment. They published an awful article on breeding your pets for profit, and despite 2 weeks of intense backlash they have posted one very poor apology. No engagement on social media at all.

  17. Julia McCoy Reply

    Fun and insightful read! It would’ve been better, I think, if smaller brands are added to the list of samples so small business owners can better relate. Awesome examples, overall. The more reason brands should be watching what is being said about them in social media, prepare response templates, and address issues online.

    Thanks much for sharing!